The 1993 Women's Suffrage Centennial
Science Conference was a watershed
in public and professional perception of women's contribution to the
body of scientific knowledge and its application in our lives.
A second conference, Science - Women and our Future, was
held in Wellington in 1996 and built on the excellence and euphoria of
the 1993 event.
Information regarding aspects of the conference area detailed on this
page:
The
Themes
The
Speakers
The
Quotes
The
Abstracts
The
Themes
This conference is an opportunity for women to
share their
experiences and enjoy a future-focused debate about where we want to
take science, how we want to participate in it and what we want from
our involvement in it.
We invite women to present papers and workshops on
the following
themes:
- what is science - what will it be tomorrow
- social responsibility, community participation,
and accessibility
- the nature and structure of the scientific
workplace
- what women are doing with their science
- ethics in science
Speakers
Kathleen Lennon,
Lecturer in Philosophy at the University of Hull, is one of the most
prominent British philosophers in her field. She works in the
philosophy of mind, philosophy of social science, and feminist theory.
In 1990 she wrote "Explaining Human Action" and has co-edited
subsequent books concerning feminist perspectives in epistemology.
Kathleen Lennon is brought to us thanks to sponsorship from the British
Council.
Dell Wihongi - Te Rarawa - is
founder of, and the inspiration behind Te Pu Hao Rangi Ethno-botanical
gardens in Tamaki Makaurau. She is one of the few people in Aotearoa
with a deep understanding of indigenous knowledge of plants. Dell also
works for the intellectual property rights of indigenous people.
Sandra Coney and Professor Robyn Rowland
are respected writers and activists on women's issues, particularly in
the areas of health and ethics. Professor Rowland is Director of the
Centre for Women's Studies at Deakin University in Australia. Sandra
Coney is well known in New Zealand for her work which lead to the
Cartwright Report.
Dale Spender is an
international expert in the fields of language, communication, writing,
publishing, and equity. She has written over 30 books and is
co-originator of WICKED, women's international knowledge encyclopaedia
and database. In addition, she is a feminist comedienne extraordinaire
and a magnificent speaker. Dale Spender is brought to us thanks to
the sponsorship from FRST.
Why
Come
Here are some of the reasons given by women who
have made this conference happen...
"...The 1993 conference was one of those
rare life-changing events. The effects of the energy levels generated
over those three days are still a force in my life..."
"...Much of modern management theory
seems similar to what women have been saying for years, about
empowerment, sharing information and types of leadership style. I want
to discuss these issues with other women..."
"...the structure of scientific endeavour
and its results is a challenging arena. How do intellectual property
rights, public access, client confidentiality get accommodated,
particularly in a dual funding regime - suggestions, discussions,
comments will be valuable..."
"...I am particularly interested in the
effects of science on society, especially the concerns of women - past,
present and future..."
"...to meet and hear the life stories of
older women in science, who have dreamed and struggled, and who offer
big hearts as well as inspiration..."
"...to share enthusiasm, joy and wonder
in our science; to celebrate the pleasure we feel at 'doing it'..."
Abstracts
BY THE LIGHT OF THE VDU; TELEWORK AND GENDERED
RELATIONS
Nicola Armstrong
Department of Sociology, Massey University
This paper will explore the working and family
lives of women and
men who work from home using 'new' information and communication
technologies (teleworkers). The focus of the discussion will be on the
use of time and space by teleworkers who have small children, in order
to examine the implications for women and men of having no spatial or
temporal boundaries between their working and "private" lives. The
paper will conclude by investigating the constructing and enabling
potential of information and communication technologies as they are
used within the home, and the implications for gender and power within
households.
NEW ZEALAND WOMEN DRIVERS - ANGELS OR DEVILS?
Margaret L Bailey
Bailey Partnership Ltd
Whitby, Porirua
This paper reviews research in New Zealand on
women drivers and
their accidents. Data are used from two studies of fatal road
accidents, an in-depth study for 1991 to 1993 and a study for 1986.
Some interesting factors relating to female drivers who have fatal
accidents are:
* Women do less drinking and driving or travelling
at excessive
speed than men.
* Young women drink and drive or speed more often
than older (over
44) women.
* Factors in the accidents of young women are
incompetence or
inexperience.
* Important factors for older women are failing to
keep left or
failing to give way. Many got their driver's licence late in life.
Three-quarters of this group are not drinking drivers or speeding
drivers.
* Women involved in a drink driving accident are
much less likely
than men to have a previous conviction for drink driving.
MAKING EQUITY PROGRESS THROUGH STRATEGIC PLANNING
METHODS
Judy Brown and Ewan Tempero
Department of Computer Science
Victoria University of Wellington
This paper discusses how to use strategic planning
methods to create
an effective EEO programme. Departments in the Science Faculty at
Victoria University of Wellington are now required to develop and
report on an annual EEO strategic plan. The planning and reporting
process is overseen by a Faculty EEO committee. An EEO plan describes
what it is trying to achieve in terms of expected outcomes. It details
what a successful outcome is, the necessary steps to achieve these
outcomes, and how the outcomes are measured. This paper describes the
strategic planning process used by the Science Faculty. It emphasizes
the importance of gathering data necessary to put the strategic
planning process into effect. This method has increased awareness of
equity issues, encouraged change and introduced a process whereby
equity can be regularly assessed. The use of strategic planning has
contributed to creating a more equitable climate within the Science
Faculty.
DOWNREGULATION WITH DIGNITY
Janet Carrington
Biochemistry Department
University of Otago, Dunedin
Do you plan for a future in science? Are you
continually amazed by
new discoveries, awed as the miracle of life unfolds, undaunted by the
publication explosion? Or are you distraught by the extent of the
literature as you struggle to concentrate and strive to understand one
scientific paper when you need to read twenty. Women expect equal
opportunity in education and employment. Because we have been able to
make choices throughout our lives we expect that to continue. If you've
been working for some time as a technician, a research fellow, a
teacher or in another position in science do you still have the ability
and drive to achieve more? After a life of coping with being female in
a science world are you equipped for being an elderly female in a
science world? Remember, there's no problem too big to run away from.
WOMEN IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
Robyn Cotton
New Zealand Dairy Board
Food Science and Technology is a sound career
option for women. It
is a growth area reflecting changing tastes and increased
sophistication of consumers, and it covers a wide range of skills.
Compared with the great inequalities of fifteen years ago, there are
now near-equal numbers of women and men employed in technical roles.
There is, however, an imbalance at the senior level. My vision for the
future is for the trend towards equality for women in industries like
the dairy industry to continue, with the equality driving up the
management chain. There are varied reasons for this: women who took
time out for parenting are now back on the career path, more women
students are enrolled in related tertiary courses, more childcare
options are available (including increasing numbers of male primary
caregivers), and general acceptance of woman in the once all-male
domain.
SHE WHO BLEEDS YET DOES NOT DIE
Vicki Culling
Applied Social Sciences
Victoria University of Wellington
Science has instituted a perception of the female
body as inferior
and problematic as compared to the male body. Menstruation has been
interpreted as evidence of that inferiority. Early Western philosophers
initiated the theories that woman is a defective version of man.
Aristotle provided the first scientific explanation of woman as
inferior. His thesis was based on the notion of heat. Women were unable
to "cook" their blood to the point of purity which would result in its
transformation into semen. Subsequent theorists adopted Aristotle's
position and expanded on his theories of woman as a misbegotten man. As
a result, the uterus was considered responsible for women's physical
well-being and eventually her mental well-being from the classical
period through to the twentieth century. This paper shall present and
discuss the early theories about woman and her menstruating body,
theories which are the foundations of our "modern" science and medicine.
WOMEN MATHEMATICIANS: EIGHT WOMEN'S EXPERIENCES
Mary Day
Department of Mathematics
Massey University, Palmerston North
This paper reports on a qualitative research
project in which women
mathematicians were interviewed about their experiences in mathematics.
It focuses on women who are successful in mathematics unlike most of
the research in this area. It reports on a qualitative research project
in which eight women were interviewed about their experiences in
mathematics. The discussion includes descriptions of how these
individuals overcame the barriers that can exist to prevent women's
full participation in mathematics and the diverse attractions
mathematics has for these women. Aspects of the culture of mathematics
that these women found difficult or at odds with their own values are
discussed. The contradictory position of these women is highlighted in
the descriptions of their involvement in women's groups and finally an
overview of the diverse ways in which these women make sense of
themselves and their experiences is given.
REGULATION OF AGRICULTURAL AND VETERINARY
CHEMICALS: WHAT'S IT ALL
ABOUT ?
Gabrielle J M Deuss
Agricultural Compounds Unit
Ministry of Agriculture, Upper Hutt
Chemicals have had partial responsibility for the
revolution in
agriculture in the twentieth century. They have helped arrest disease
outbreaks, prevent the occurrence of disease, kill pests of importance,
and improve agricultural yields. New Zealand regulators are committed
to providing government and the public with the best available
information and advice. New legislation will allow for a holistic
approach to agricultural compounds, with the Hazardous Substances and
New Organisms Legislation bringing various existing controls under a
single piece of legislation. Decision makers will follow the
precautionary principle, and applicants will have their products
assessed against sets of performance based standards. Recognising New
Zealand's position as an exporting nation, the Agricultural Compounds
Legislation will allow for special controls to be added to take account
of market access requirements. These legislative initiatives are part
of government commitment to a sustainable future for this country in
all areas of activity.
ENTHUSIASM IN SCIENCE
Lyn Dowsett
Teaching Fellow
University of Otago, Dunedin
While I was writing this abstract and reflecting
on the subject of
enthusiasm, I thought I would write down all the words I could think of
that contributed to the essence of enthusiasm. Thirty words later I
decided that the topic was even more interesting than I had
anticipated. For me, enthusiasm is part and parcel of living and doing.
In my subject of Biochemistry, which so many anxious students tell me
is difficult and dull, I find it can lift the mood of the class and
engage attention where other visual aids will fail. Enthusiasm can move
mountains and revitalise people. In this workshop I would like to
explore how we can use enthusiasm to enhance the learning process, our
own and that of other people. We can work together to maximise our
enthusiastic effectiveness. Within the limitations of a 90 minute
workshop, we should be able to sharpen our power to wield enthusiasm as
a tool. Enthusiasm can see you through really sticky patches when all
the experiments seem to fail, all the deadlines are looming at once and
someone ate the last of the manuka honey. Participants should come
prepared to share their enthusiams and incidents in which they have
used that enthusiasm to power their lives. They should come prepared to
share their enthusiams and incidents in which they have used that
enthusiasm to power their lives.
WOMEN IN AFRICA: A VISITING KIWI SCIENTIST'S
IMPRESSIONS
Kerry R. Everett
HortResearch, Te Puke
Part of any scientist's career are research visits
to other
countries. During that time, as well as furthering scientific knowledge
and experience, encounters with other cultures can enrich and challenge
one's own values and ideas. I would like to share some of my
experiences and impressions of the status of women in Africa that I
obtained during a 6-month research visit to the University of Pretoria,
Republic of South Africa. The burdens women have to bear in Sub-Saharan
Africa are disturbing to someone of my ethnocentric point of view. I
will also discuss the thesis that if women were more empowered in this
part of the world, famine in Africa would not exist.
LIFE AND DEATH IN REPRODUCTIVE BIOLOGY
Jean S Fleming
Physiology Department
Otago School of Medical Sciences, Dunedin
In 1990 I was awarded the very first Zonta Award.
At the time I was
a MAFTech Postdoctoral Fellow, working on reproductive gene expression
in the superfertile Booroola sheep. The Zonta Award took me one and a
half times around the world and helped me establish a network of
colleagues in Britain, France and the US. From 1990 to 1992 I continued
to study the expression of reproductive hormone genes in the Booroola,
work which led to a continuing interest in the role of the activin and
inhibin genes in development. I simultaneously became fascinated by a
highly sulphated glycoprotein called clusterin, which appears to be
involved in the protection of gametes during development, but is also
associated with programmed cell death or apoptosis. Today I teach
endocrinology and reproduction to students in the Otago Medical School
and continue to do research on activins and clusterin in reproductive
biology.
A printable pdf file of Jean Fleming's paper is
available by clicking here.
ASSESSING SCIENCE LEARNING
Sharleen D Forbes
Statistics New Zealand, Wellington
The achievement of women in science, as a group,
has often been
measured against that of men in terms of their participation and
performance in science learning at various levels. The objectivity of
testing procedures designed to measure performance is usually in terms
of validity and reliability for the whole population of students. There
has been comparatively little research to identify the contribution
made by the form of the assessment itself. The National Qualifications
Framework promotes a move from norm-referenced written examinations to
standards-based assessment. My research in mathematics education gives
a preliminary indication that the performance of various groups is
related to the form of the assessment. It is time for teachers and
learners of science, together with science practitioners, to
systematically evaluate the specific skills being evaluated by
different forms of assessment and to determine which of these skills
are the desired attributes of a scientist.
EXPLORING NON-CONVENTIONAL WORK OPTIONS IN THE
SCIENCE COMMUNITY
Ellen Förch
Consultant
& The Open Polytechnic of New Zealand, Lower
Hutt
The myth of the 40 hour week and its deleterious
effect on the
ability of the family woman to function in the workplace is explored.
Nine different work options are presented as well as the author's
experience of the advantages, disadvantages and other considerations
surrounding these options. Strategies are presented for maintaining a
credible profile. The two key elements are considered to be the
negotiated deployment of time and maximising perceptions of value to
the employer. Recent changes in the science sector offer new
opportunities for women. These are principally better accountability
for time, opportunities for better defined contributions, and the
increased emphasis on relevance and client needs. Changes in the
science sector are giving rise to new career options in associated
administration, commerce and public relations.
THE SCIENCE OF NURSING
June Friedel
Lecturer
Manukau Institute of Technology, Auckland
Nursing is predominantly a female profession,
which is currently
raising its academic status. It requires an unusual mix of skills and
knowledge, including communication and caring skills, biological and
physical sciences, sociology, and psychology, as well as nursing
knowledge and praxis. The science content in particular seems to cause
students difficulty, because of teaching methods, the type of teacher,
a lack of prior knowledge, or lack of application to practice. Many
girls to not study science to high levels at school, but are expected
to study scientific topics as part of a nursing curriculum. Scientific
knowledge is clearly essential for skilled nursing practice, but it is
not yet clear exactly what that knowledge should be. As the academic
discipline of nursing has developed, it has not incorporated bioscience
into nursing theories. One solution to students' difficulty with
science is described, and other continuing problems are discussed.
COMMUNICATING SCIENCE TO THE COMMUNITY
Sue Galloway
AgResearch Molecular Biology Unit
University of Otago, Dunedin
Most of us with formal science training are
accustomed to
communicating our science in ways that are incredibly limited to
specialised conferences and publications. Our audience is a small
minority privileged to understand the terms and style we use. By
restricting communication to our peers we deny others access to
exciting ideas and knowledge. In a technological age it is important
that scientific ideas are available to all. This workshop is for anyone
with an interest in communicating science at any level and will explore
ways of presenting science so that we can explain it clearly to our
communities. We'll discuss practical ways to translate difficult
concepts, and participants will be equipped with ideas, enthusiasm and
encouragement to continually look for ways to do this in the wider
community. By discovering how to communicate effectively with our
community, we may also uncover new ways to communicate with our peers
within the scientific community.
GENDER AND SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY: AN
INTERNATIONAL OVERVIEW
Elizabeth Godfrey
The University of Auckland, New Zealand
Attendance at the eighth international GASAT (
Gender and Science
and Technology) conference in India in January 1996 brought more
questions than answers. Since its formation in the early eighties this
association/network has, through its biennial conferences and their
proceedings, been a primary source of research findings, models of
`good practice' and in-depth analyses of the relationship of gender to
science and technology. In particular, the nineties have seen a major
shift in the focus of action and research from `changing the girls' to
`changing the science'. The GASAT community continues to examine what
this might mean for issues such as gender-inclusive curricula, the
professional culture of science and engineering, and priorities for
research. In this paper we share some of the initiatives and findings
of the GASAT community as we work towards empowering women to take
their place in a world in which science and technology continue to play
an ever increasing role.
COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION IN ETHICAL DELIBERATION
Sarah Gordon and Marie van Wyk
Otago University, Dunedin
Moral deliberation ought to be a community
enterprise. Yet many
ethical decision-making structures, within hospitals and parliament,
continued to be dominated by a select few. Feminist ethics recognised
the importance of allowing more voices to be heard, and is committed to
the goal of democratic empowerment. Two summer studentships undertaken
at the Otago Bioethics Research Centre focused on empowering vulnerable
groups to contribute more to discussion and decision-making in the
field of ethics. 'Euthanasia: Resources for Community Discussion' is a
kit designed to inform groups of the main ethic issues relating to
euthanasia. 'Methods of Resolving Clinical Ethical Dilemmas' focuses on
multi-disciplinary clinical ethics decisions and programmes of on-going
ethics education.
SEXISM AND SCIENTISM IN THE ENCLAVE OF THE
'SOUTHERN MAN'
Sue Hanham and Dr Brian Ballantyne
Dept of Surveying
University of Otago, Dunedin
Women are significantly under-represented in
surveying in New
Zealand. In 1966 14% of students at the Otago University's Surveying
Department are women. Within the surveying profession 2% are women. A
1993 study by the authors indicated that gender barriers - both over
and covert - do exist. The purpose of this paper is three-fold.
Firstly, the situation in the Surveying Department is reviewed three
years on (in light of our 1993 proposals). Secondly, we suggest an
hypothesis that sexism within surveying (as within most non-traditional
professions) is merely a subset of scientism. This is, perhaps gender
barriers are merely a function of a mindset for whom pursuit of numbers
is paramount. Thirdly, we conclude by proposing a research agenda to
increase the number of women in surveying and to develop a climate of
tolerance, inclusion and social responsibility within surveying.
"SWITCHING ON" THE INNOVATORS OF TOMORROW
Elizabeth G. Heij
CSIRO Horticulture
Adelaide, South Australia
Have you ever thought about relationships between
data, information,
explicit knowledge, and tacit knowledge? Or wondered how creativity and
innovation can be enhanced or inhibited by information and management
systems? Our increasingly bulky, prescriptive management and education
systems seem to be discouraging rather than fostering innovation, and
this at a time when increasing rates of change demand more rapid
innovation responses. Our graduates are stuffed with yesterday's
information, but are they trained to make things happen in an
increasingly labile future? Can they make the connections between tacit
and explicit knowledge that innovation requires? Our corporate managers
follow the latest management fads, but are they stimulating creativity
or minimising the chances for it to occur? One of the saddest lessons I
have learned from today's managerial environment is that it is quite
possible to have 60-80 hours per week full to crisis point with urgent
tasks and be bored to death at the same time. Haven't we forgotten how
important it is to have FUN - to play - to have some unstructured time
in which to think, to pursue different experiences, and to fiddle with
"off-the-wall" ideas? I propose we need to take a new look at academic
training, research, and general management in light of the real
requirements for creative thought.
FRENCH FEMINISTS AND MICHAEL FOUCAULT
Annette Huntington & Jean Gilmour
School of Nursing
Wellington Polytechnic, Wellington
Some French philosophers have challenged the taken
for granted
assumptions underpinning the scientific enterprise. In particular
French feminists and Michael Foucault, whilst having very significant
points of difference, have commonalities in their stance that
knowledge, positioned as being the 'truth' at any particular time, is
historically specified and open to transformation. Many researchers
working within interpretative and critical paradigms are confronted
with the work of Michael Foucault, whose influence has spread across
disciplines. The French feminists' theoretical perspectives are a major
force in contemporary feminist thinking and their work directly
challenges much of mainstream Anglo-American feminist philosophy. In
this paper we will discuss how we have used the ideas of the French
feminists and Foucault in our current research, which is focused on the
construction and control of bodies in specific health settings.
WHOSE VIEW? DOING QUALITATIVE RESEARCH
G R Jamieson
Department of Education, University of Otago
'Listen to my voice, it is a blend of many voices.
I am a graduate
student, a wife, a daughter, an erotic dancer, a friend; the quantity
of potential identities stretch into infinity ...' With the increasing
recognition of the importance of the social context on people's lives
there is an intersection of traditional and social sciences. My aim in
this workshop about qualitative methods is to explore the subjective
judgements made at all stages of the research process. Participants
will have the opportunity to listen to an introduction about my
experiences with qualitative research and then to discuss some of the
important issues which are confronted by all of the parties who become
involved, for example, What are some of the ethical issues? Who will
gain from the research? Whose opinions will be given in the final
report? How will the research change the lives of the participants?
What, if anything, will the different parties gain, or lose? What
assumptions are brought to the research? How can the researcher extend
her ability to see other people's realities? Validity, reliability,
quality and credibility will also be considered.
PUBLISHING NEW ZEALAND SCIENCE
Frances Kell, Gill Sutherland
SIR Publishing, Wellington
There are many options available in New Zealand
and overseas for the
publication of New Zealand science, from fully refereed journals to
popular magazines. Most research results are published in refereed
journals. Before submitting an unsolicited paper or article to any
publication, an author should be sure that the subject matter is within
the scope of the publication, that the paper has undergone peer review
(by colleagues), that the presentation of the manuscript conforms to
the requirements of the publication in format and number of copies, and
that it has not been submitted to or published in any other
publication. A paper submitted to a journal is sent to two editorially
selected referees for critical review. Acting on the referees' advice,
the editor may reject the paper, or may require the author(s) to revise
the paper before it is accepted for publication.
PERSONAL POWER - REGAINING IT!
Carolyn Lane and Jane McCann
McCann Consultancy, Wellington
The purpose of this workshop is to assist women to
identify their
POWER and success strategies and have fun in the process. The session
will look at how people communicate with themselves about their use of
power and success and how this internal communication can shape their
lives, their beliefs and their behaviour. The workshop will be highly
interactive and fun. It will involve assisting women to challenge their
belief systems and the negative messages that they repeat to themselves
that keep them disempowered. At the end of the workshop participants
will have ... analysed the behaviours that result from these beliefs,
worked out ways of replacing these beliefs with new ones, and come away
feeling EMPOWERED!
RETHINKING WOMEN AND SCIENCE
Kathleen Lennon
Department of Philosophy
University of Hull
Feminist intellectual engagement with science
emerged out of key
political encounters between feminist activists and scientific experts;
most notably the womens health and reproductive rights movement, peace
movements, and environmental movements. These set the political
background to the intellectual critiques of science as 'male', in both
the areas it researches and the narratives it weaves about them. The
resultant projects to feminize science provided some crucial rethinking
of our relationship to the world we investigate. However they also
proved problematically restrictive ,and in danger of reinforcing an
oppositional relation between femininity and advanced scientific and
technological expertise. What has remained central, however, has been
attention to the constitution of our scientific communities, and the
answerability of scientists to other communities they are part of. This
points the way to developing empowering scientific narratives while
simultaneously requiring us to reconsider our conceptions of
objectivity and truth.
SCIENCE GROUP MANAGEMENT: GETTING THERE AND
ENJOYING IT
Louise A. Malone
Horticulture and Food Research Institute of New
Zealand, Auckland
he intention of this presentation is to offer
encouragement to women
interested in moving into management in the CRI environment. The author
will draw on her own experience to present possible strategies for
women to adopt in order to pursue this career path and will highlight
the positive aspects of taking on a management role within a research
organisation. In order to make the presentation accessible and useful
to as many women as possible, it will not take the form of a detailed
personal history. A broad overview of the job and practical advice on
how to get there (without having to be "superwoman") will be given. It
is hoped that a general discussion will follow, with input from other
managers as well as those aspiring to such positions.
WOMEN'S ROLE AT CAWTHRON 1920-1996
Lorraine MacIntosh
Cawthron Institute, Nelson
Cawthron has occupied a unique position in NZ
science starting from
a private bequest. The first research was agricultural and the founding
staff consisted of approximately ten, with one woman, Dr Kathleen
Curtis. The role of women at Cawthron has been consistent with women's
role in society over this period. The first women scientists pursued
their careers at considerable personal cost and predominantly work in
the biological sciences or in support services. Notable exceptions were
Elsa Kidson and Joyce Watson, both scientists. The war years saw a
dramatic increase in the number of women employees but male-dominated
attitudes predominated to the 1970s. The formation of a technical
service section resulted in increased numbers of women working in the
laboratories. Those involved with research work have never been above
25%. Cawthron today employs 85 staff, of which half are women. There is
one women manager and one woman scientist. The current Chief Executive
is support of women, but the women generally see their lifestyle
choices (family & c) as incompatible with the effort and commitment
necessary to achieve in their science careers.
BECOMING A COMPANY DIRECTOR
Jenny Morel
Wellington
This workshop will look at:
* what is involved in being a director
* what makes a good board
* the roles, functions and operations of the board
* legal duties and liabilities of the board
* directors' liability
* 'Do you want to be a Director?'
REMARKABLY REFRESHING RESEARCHERS: HOW ARE THEY
CREATING OUR FUTURE?
Sue Muggleston
HortResearch, Auckland
An overview of some of the projects in
HortResearch that are aimed
at producing plant cultivars for the future. The ways in which this
research is expected to change the face of horticulture and other
related industries in New Zealand will be discussed. These include
conventional breeding and biotechnological solutions to pest and
disease problems and development of improved plant and fruit
characteristics. On the lighter side, some of the women carrying out
this research will be profiled and their diverse and fascinating lives
revealed!
EEO IN THE CRI'S - A NIWA PERSPECTIVE
Adrienne Murray
General Manager Human Resources
NIWA, Wellington
"A working environment where everyone is able to
participate and
compete equitably, to develop their full potential and to be regarded
fairly regardless of gender, ethnicity, disability, sexual orientation,
age or family circumstances is what I want" she said ... and he replied
" but we have that, I'm not aware of any problems" ... "well, this is
where it's not working" she said and explained to him why the
inequities continue ... This workshop will provide an opportunity to
look at initiatives being taken in NIWA to move towards an equitable
environment and provide a workshop environment to discuss these types
of initiatives and the barriers to success. Information on initiatives
and barriers to success will be shared with other CRI's following the
conference.
GENETIC RESEARCH: THE ETHICS OF CHOOSING METAPHORS
Sylvia Nagl and Barbara Nicholas
Researchers, Christchurch
Metaphors condition the ways in which we
experience and construct
our social and material worlds. In the paper we argue that our choice
of metaphors is an ethical choice, a decision about what sort of social
world we wish to construct, reproduce or transform, and we then explore
the implications of this for genetics research. Starting from recent
feminist analysis of the ways in which biological fertilisation has
been described in the language of romance we show how metaphors shape
the social meanings of scientific explanations and the paths along
which research proceeds. In contemporary scientific and social
discourse, metaphors have been used as powerful devices for investing
DNA with extraordinary powers of agency and control. Increasingly
'genes' are seen as determining a persons state of health, personality
and character. This cultural meaning of DNA and genes is being shaped
around metaphors of 'the master molecule', the 'genetic blueprint', the
ultimate 'text', and the 'God particle'. ... Network metaphors in the
life sciences lead to questions profoundly different from those
elicited by metaphors of control: How to the properties of genes and
molecules depend on mutual interaction, pattern, and context? And, how
would finding answers to these questions change the ways in which we
see and create our world?
FEAR OF SCIENCE - WOMEN'S HISTORIES
Connie Nobles
Southeastern Louisiana University
Hammond, Louisiana USA
In this, our 1996 conference as we gather together
and celebrate who
we are and our future, it is important for us to reflect on our
histories as women in science. Through researching and writing
historical vignettes, more knowledge and appreciation for women is
gained. In my studies with preservice elementary education teachers in
the United States, I meet the fear and sometimes hatred for science
expressed and experienced by many of these college seniors. In this
writing process, students choose a woman scientist to study. As the
student-authors research, they become personally involved with the life
of the chosen scientist and study the history and nature of science as
well. Participants will be introduced to this interrupted story line
process which should challenge them to enter into reflection and
decision making with the vignette from a scientist's life. Personal
histories graphically reveal our journey as women with the struggles
and pain that accompanies change-still necessary as we advance toward
the new millennium.
TELEWORKING - MORE THAN JUST TECHNOLOGY IN THE
HOME
Judy Owen
Education Review Office
Wellington
Much has been written about the concept of
teleworking and the
impact on the employer (cost savings, higher productivity) and cities
(less traffic congestion, lower unemployment). Less has been written
about the impact on the workers. Teleworking can be broadly defined as
"using computers and telecommunications to extend aspects of the
working environment beyond the traditional workplace." Teleworking has
not taken off in New Zealand as widely as was expected. This workshop
will focus on aspects of teleworking that impact on women workers. It
aims to assist women who would like to pursue the idea further by
providing an opportunity to: explore the issues, promote the concept to
their employers, and work through individual issues for women to
actively want to telework. The format of this workshop will be
facilitated principal practical forum where the known major issues for
women will be highlighted and used as a basis for discussion.
A POLICY OF SURVIVAL - WOMEN WORKING WITH SHEEP
IN SOUTHERN MEXICO
Althea Parry
University of Chiapas, San Cristobal de Las Casas
This paper provides a colourful insight into the
lives of some
strong women whose beautiful smiles and everyday struggles to survive
brought a new meaning of science and an understanding of survival to a
NZ woman scientist in search of something more. In the highlands of
Chiapas, in southern Mexico, there are thousands of Tzotzil women (of
Mayan descent) who work hard, patiently managing small flocks of sheep
in the tradition of their ancestors. Their needs were simple - survival
of themselves, their families, and the sheep and shepherding
traditions. Good quality wool was in demand, and some women agreed to
work with us at our research farm. My western science ways were
constantly challenged, and to aid my own survival, I learnt new ways to
look and to seen, new ways to listen and to speak and to open myself to
a new science with soul.
WHOSE ETHICS ARE THEY ANYWAY?
Regina Peretini
Ngati Kahungunu & Rangitane
In 1988 Judge Sylvia Cartwright released her
report on the findings
into the Cervical Screening Inquiry; what has actually happened since
then? Has it made research safe? What infrastructure was established to
ensure good ethical review of protocols? What is the current
relationship between ethics committees? How much of a voice do
communities of interest have into the work of ethics committees? What
are some of the major problem areas in processing research protocols
through ethics committees? And what are some of the more pressing
issues that need to be addressed by the wider community - e.g., gene
manipulation, artificial reproductive technology?
THE YES TRAP
Jacqueline S. Rowarth
Plant Science Department
Lincoln University, Canterbury
Women have a thicker corpus callosum than men.
This is a column of
neurones forming electrical connenctions which provide the link between
the left hemisphere (analytical operations and logical processes) and
right hemisphere (visualisation, synthesis and creativity) of the
brain. It is believed to be the body which allows one to do more than
one thing at a time. This means that, in general, women are capable of
doing several things at once, to the detriment of none. When this
ability is combined with the characteristic of 'liking to please' plus
a desire to achieve, we are heading for the 'yes trap'. Time management
and the importance of life planning are discussed in this paper. Women
start with the advantage of a large corpus callosum and we are often
innately good time managers; the major problem is in overcoming the
belief that the only way up is as a polymathic SuperWoman.....
ENERGY EXPENDITURE AND METABOLIC FUEL ALLOCATION
IN POLYNESIAN AND
CAUCASIAN FEMALES IN RELATION TO WEIGHT GAIN AND OBESITY
Elaine Rush
Department of Applied Science
Auckand Institute of Technology, Auckland
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions in New
Zealand but reasons
for weight gain are not clear. A unique New Zealand study using stable
isotope technology to look at predictors of weight gain in eighty-two
young Polynesian and Caucasian women has been undertaken at the
Auckland Institute of Technology. We have measured body composition and
body mass index, metabolic rate, carbohydrate and fat utilisation,
physical activity by total energy expenditure using the doubly labelled
water technique and the proportion of fat in the diet by 7 day self
reported food diary. The findings point to a metabolic "thrifty
genotype" and could explain why some women find it more difficult than
others to control their weight by diet and exercise.
'HANDS-ON-SCIENCE' BIOCHEMISTRY FOR HIGH SCHOOLS:
ENERGY FROM BOTH
SIDES OF THE CAMP
Ann E. Schofield
Cancer Genetics Laboratory, Department of
Biochemistry
University of Otago, Dunedin
My workshop will be based on my rewarding
experiences in the recent
Hands-On-Science summer camp for high school children that was recently
held in Otago University. I had 2 aims: - To spread my enthusiasm for
carrying out Hands-On-Science courses - To explore some of the
important issues that arose during my participation, for example: - Who
is the ideal tutor for such a course: a researcher or a teacher? - How
necessary is discipline and structure in the Hands-On-Science courses?
- What makes women such successful teachers? - What are the most
appropriate teaching styles in such a forum? We are constantly teaching
and learning in every aspect of our lives. But how often do we think
about and discuss the most successful ways of performing each of these
important tasks? The answer to this question is "Not often", so here is
your chance!!
MENTORING - A TWICE-BLESSED ACTIVITY
Karen Sole
Workplace Consultant
Wellington South
What developmental tool is effective, fiscally
neutral, able to be
utilised in any work environment, and has a long history of empowering
women? Mentoring. ... Mentoring is an activity twice blessed. Find out
why, and how, at a participatory, woman positive workshop. Focus on the
mentor pair; essential elements of a successful mentor relationship;
benefits and pitfalls; and skills required by both parties. The
environment will be safe, stimulating, and supportive. Notes will be
provided. The workshop is limited to 20 participants.
IT'S NOT A SUPERHIGHWAY - IT'S MORE LIKE A
VILLAGE SQUARE
Dale Spender
To call cyberspace a superhighway says more about
the men who have
done the naming than it does about the new forms of communication. And
while (white, American speaking) men have made up the terms it's not
surprising that women might not want to take a turn at 'hot rod
computing' ... But when we see cyberspace as a meeting place, a village
square where a community meets to exchange information, then it all
looks very different. An information bazaar where women can not only
hear what others have to say - but where they can make their own voices
heard - is a place that has an enormous attraction for women. The
challenge for women is to get away from the technological mindset and
to shape the new forms of communication. We are in the process of
creating a new community, and women must make the most of the
opportunity to create a cybersociety which reflects their values and
interests. This means engaging with the computer culture - at every
level.
A CASE STUDY USING FRESHNESS TESTS AND
ORIENTATION JUDGEMENTS IN
LATENT PALMPRINT EVIDENCE
L Jayne Sutherland
New Zealand Police
Wellington
This paper outlines the method of overlaying
transparencies used to
demonstrate the orientation of a lifted palmprint (Police v Harbour,
Napier High Court, May 1994) and describes freshness tests carried out
to support the palmprint evidence presented to the jury during the
trial. A 32-year-old man had been charged with Kidnapping, Injury and
Sexual Assault of a young boy in Flaxmere, Hastings. The accused raised
two issues about his palmprint found at the scene, (1) it had
legitimately been left there, (2) it had been placed at least 12 months
prior to the offence. Conclusions reached and presented in evidence
were (1) that the palmprint was of much more recent origin than the one
year claimed, and (2) the print must have been placed on the window
frame with the pane out of its surround.
CELEBRATING DIVERSITY: EEO IN SCIENCE
ORGANISATIONS
Trish Tapara
HortResearch
Auckland
The workshop will assist women to identify the
Equal Employment
Opportunity status of their organisation and to develop strategies to
promote EEO projects such as workplace networks, work and family
policy, career development for women, strategies for women into
management, harassment prevention in the workplace. A group process
emphasising participation and practical outcomes will be facilitated by
HortWomen, members of the HortResearch women's network. After a brief
introduction to the topics of Work and Family, Career Development, and
EEO Policy and Human Resource Practice, participants will divide into
three groups, which will each focus on one of these topics. Developing
strategies to implement similar projects within other organisations
will focus on how to utilise legislation and business imperatives as
promotional tools, breaking down barriers and identifying allies. There
will be the opportunity to use the resources available and access
resource lists on each topic. Feedback from each group will enable all
participants to share information to take back to their organisations.
WOMEN AND THE SCIENCE OF FINGERPRINTS - AN
INTRODUCTION
Michelle S Tingey
New Zealand Police
Wellington
Over 100 years ago the theory of using the ridged
skin on the
underside of the hand as a means of personal identification was
developed. The characteristics of ridged skin were found to be unique
to each individual. The theory developed into a science that has a
primary application in Police forces of the world, i.e., the positive
identification of prisoners and the development and identification of
latent fingerprints at scenes of crime and presentation of those
findings in the courts of law. The NZ Fingerprint Section began in 1903
and over the last 20 years women have joined the section. Today, in New
Zealand there are 31 fingerprint experts, five of whom are women. There
are seven women trainees. All have varied science backgrounds and the
potential to take the science into the next century and contribute to
its continued development in New Zealand.
SCIENCE IN PERSPECTIVE: RECENT PHILOSOPHICAL
INSIGHTS AND A
PRACTICAL EXAMPLE OF MAKING SCIENCE RELEVANT AND ACCESSIBLE TO SOCIETY
Pam Walker
(MORST)
Jo Blakeley, June Stratton, and Tina Gehrke
(The Open Polytechnic of New Zealand)
To clarify some difficulties at the interface of
science and
communities, a brief history of western perceptions of the value and
validity of three different kinds of knowledge is given: empirical/
analytical knowledge (science), inter- subjective understanding
(intuition) and emancipatory knowledge (that knowledge which provides
freedom from ideology and mental coercion or domination). Influences
from the Enlightenment and this century have brought about the
depressed role of the latter. This can limit the effectiveness of
scientific knowledge unless it is brought back into context. To secure
public judgement science needs to be accessible and relevant. Those
learning science need to graduate with a more open mind about the
nature of science than when they entered their studies. They need to be
more critical of "facts" so that they can seek new knowledge. In
developing a new first year degree course, Science for Environmental
Management, course developers have had to review the relevance of
science to life. Having an environmental perspective has introduced
science into an holistic framework where the whole is greater than the
sum of the parts, where science is seen in an humanitarian perspective,
where science takes on a subjective role. The result is a course that
empowers the individual to have input into science and shows that
science is relevant and workable to everyday life.
WHENUA AND MATAURANGA
Dell Wihongi
Pu Hao Rangi Trust
In the face of rapid transformation of the Earth
by science and
technology, and the ecological crisis that has begun to unfold, leading
thinkers are exploring the alternative cosmologies, paradigms and
philosophies in search of models that may sustain nature rather than
destroy it. Many of these thinkers have found the indigenous
cosmologies offer some of the most profound insights for cultivating
the kind of sustainable relationship to whenua and the spiritually
integrated perception of nature needed to address what has now become a
global crisis of ecological relationship.
WHAT CAN WE GAIN FROM AN ENGINEERING CAREER AND
WHAT CAN WE GIVE IN
RETURN?
Sarah Wills
Kingston Morrison Ltd, Wellington
Share an hour and a half of debate, direction,
enthusiasm and
networking. The workshop, targeted at any woman who considers herself
to be an Engineer, will interest and stimulate all focussed women from
graduates to shareholders. The known benefits of an engineering career
will be compared with the desired benefits to establish pro-active
strategies to make changes and satisfy our goals. The keys to success
and the importance of planning will also be discussed. Aimed at
motivating engineers, the workshop will provide an opportunity for each
woman to begin to fully participate in the direction she wants her
career to take.
|